Thoughtful comments and respectful opinions on the switch from Marshall Field's to Macy's are welcome below. Off-topic, slanderous, disrespectful or abusive posts will not be included at the host's discretion, although an attempt will be made to contact the author, assuming a valid email address is provided with the post. Please remember that this is a blog for opinions of Field's Fans. Due to problems with spam, posts are moderated and may take several hours to appear. Thank you for your patience.
HOME | Enewsletter | Leaflets | Pin-on Buttons | Shopping Guide | About This Site
Date: Sat, September 6, 2008 9:39 am CT
Posted by: A Field's Fan
Just a heads up if you are in a hurry:
You can also leave Sun-Times Talk Back comments by phone at (312) 321-2360. Even if they do not use your brief comment, it does register as a sort of poll for Field's as far as the editors are concerned! You can do it in a minute! Just a minute today to help bring back Field's!
Date: Sat, September 6, 2008 9:01 am CT
Posted by: A Field's Fan
Page 23 of today's Saturday Chicago Sun-Times features Macy's as well as mention of our Tuesday rally in the Business In Brief column. Although it is short, it's clear it deserves replies from we who are Field's supporters:
Macy's will introduce 23 collections by Chicago-based fashion designers on Oct. 1 to kick off Fashion Focus Chicago.
The designers were nominated by members of the Mayor's Fashion Council. Macy's continues to revamp its State Street store to appeal to local tastes, but Marshall Field's & Co. fans plan a protest rally Tuesday to bring back Field's. Macy's changed the name and brought in its own brands on Sept. 9, 2006.
The brief is also online at http://www.suntimes.com/lifestyles/fashion/1147847,CST-FIN-macy06WEB.article
The Sun-Times allows comments online after the piece; however, you must register with some identity--although that can remain pretty anonymous. You can then use that to comment on any Sun-Times article.
And of course you can email your comments to their editorial page at letters@suntimes.com and their TalkBack column at talkback@suntimes.com
See you at the Tuesday rally!
Date: Fri, September 5, 2008 11:19 pm CT
Posted by: JasonM
A good way to effect potential shoppers is to comment on yelp. I've posted some thoughts about macy's (especially for the Europeans who are going to spend their Euros there).
Take a moment to yelp about macy's and give others ideas on where else to shop.
Date: Fri, September 5, 2008 8:15 pm CT
Posted by: Jane
I haven't posted for a while, but I continue to read everyone's comments and share in your hope that Marshall Field's return.
The purpose of this post is to report that my observations in recent pass throughs of the Northbrook and Mayfair Macy's stores--two stores which truly represented Marshall Field's at its best. Although I was a Regards customer of Field's and had a Field's charge since 1962, Macy's has made it clear that I am no longer a target Macy's customer, and hence, I don't buy...but I do walk through and take it all in, commenting loudly at how dirty and hopeless the stores are.
Macy's has stopped selling St. John, at least that was my observation upon passing through the Mayfair and Northbrook stores on recent shopping trips. This had been a profitable line under Field's--so popular that the most common sizes would never make it to the sale rack. (Ooops! forgot that mentioning "sale" puts me into the category of one of those bad people that Macy's doesn't want to attract as customers--despite all its own junk brands on sale each day of the week.) Also gone are the higher end handbags sold at these outposts in recent years (i.e., Judith Lieber). Speaking of high end, does anyone out there remember when Field's sold Gucci in the 1980's?
Macy's has also eliminated all high end crystal and china from Mayfair and Northbrook. Brands like Baccarat, Lalique, Kosta Boda, Haviland, etc. are all gone. In their places...boxed sets. I know for a fact that the high end brands sold at Field's (and they NEVER went on sale), as I know a former sales associate from the Mayfair china/crystal department.
Macy's has also elminated sterling silver flatware for sale at these stores. I'm expecting my next walk through will feature Martha Stewart plastic utensils, sold in a vending machine, in its place.
Also gone are the printed invitations, high end (Waterman, Mont Blanc, etc.) pens and any sort of stationary department.
Not to forget the men...Mayfair's Lacoste Department is now gone, and they no longer sell men's leather goods like Bosca and Tumi. I did not check at Northbrook.
As for children, the selections are in poor taste. The brands I used to buy for my grandchildren are no longer there. Who can blame kids for wanting Abercrombie and American Eagle? Lots more style for less money.
Now recall the Macy's promise: it was going to keep all the same brands as Field's...only the name would change. What a joke.
I have said it before, and I will say it again. If the American Department Store is indeed dead, why not turn it around and bring it back to the glory days? Macy's, which proclaimed it would keep the best of Field's, has turned away the most loyal customers it had in the Field's market.
While I relate to those who mourn the loss of the most recent visions of Field's, we can't really say that the Field's of recent years was anything like what it was pre-1985ish, but even in recent years, it was MUCH, MUCH better than what it is now under Macy's.
While I miss the Field's of five years ago, I really long for the Field's of, say 1970. There's no reason that type of experience cannot be brought back...but unfortunately, the people at Macy's are incapable of doing so.
Thanks for listening.
Date: Fri, September 5, 2008 6:17 pm CT
Posted by: Pete
How can these Macy's folks keep making up excuses for not bringing back Field's??? It's clear it's what Chicago customers want!
Date: Fri, September 5, 2008 3:50 pm CT
Posted by: Alfred in Washington
Hi, Field's Fans. Can't wait to see you Tuesday--at both the noon rally and Joan Greene's talk in the evening. A day to celebrate the once and future Marshall Field's!
Date: Fri, September 5, 2008 12:34 pm CT
Posted by: From Frederick, MD
After living in Chicago, I moved out East. But I still continued to order from Marshall Field's.
We have a Macy's in Frederick (I've never been in it) but it's not Marshall Fields and never will be--there's a big difference. Thank you and I hope to see Marshall Fields return very soon in the future!
Date: Fri, September 5, 2008 9:54 am CT
Posted by: gle
Ugh!
"Macy's livens up State Street space" by Sandra M. Jones in today's "Tribune"
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/chi-fri-notebook-retail-macys-sep05,0,4446465.story
This one says Messy's is targeting the guys and the lunch hour and after-work crowd. That sounds like a lot of us. See all of "us" OUTSIDE at the rally September 9!
Letters to ctc-TribLetter@tribune.com and smjones@tribune.com. Post on the comment blog too.
Date: Fri, September 5, 2008 1:26 am CT
Posted by: A.
It used to be such a wonderful store. I have never set foot in Macy's and will never do so. I just couldn't!
Date: Thurs, September 4, 2008 7:43 pm CT
Posted by: Gail S., Lake Bluff
This evening after work, I was walking by the store that once was our beloved Marshall Field's on State Street. A man was standing in the rain passing out cards about a rally and book signing. It also included this web page. I want to say how nice it was to be told "Thank you, Madame" when given the card. It reminded me of what Field's was and Macy's is not.
I miss the store in Lake Forest too.
Gail S.
Date: Thurs, September 4, 2008 3:02 pm CT
Posted by: L. Grand
Wow. I just got back from the Tommy Hilfiger website to check out the latest from that company - out of curiosity of course. While I was open-minded upon arrival, I quickly found myself experiencing an emotion that has been felt when thinking about macy*s. This emotion can only be expressed with one word:
UGH....
It's truly no surprise that macy's and Hilfiger are teaming up. They're both exclusive all right. Hundreds of thousands or more shoppers will EXCLUDE ourselves from embracing the "magic" of macy's! UGH!
Date: Thurs, September 4, 2008 12:40 pm CT
Posted by: Gayle
Hi all, below is a link to a self-help website that suggests going to Macy's to try new fashions! Ugh, like Tommy and Martha?
You don't need to sign up to leave comments---this is a new avenue for reaching people, so please leave a comment!
http://www.first30days.com/everyday-change/2008/09/04.html
gayle
Date: Thurs, September 4, 2008 7:32 am CT
Posted by: A Field's Fan
While the Tribune on-line ran that whole story from the AP on the Tommy Hilfiger line at Macy's, today's newspaper only featured a photo without the story.
Date: Thurs, September 4, 2008 12:13 am CT
Posted by: J.H.
Thanks & keep up the great work!
Date: Wed, September 3, 2008 9:43 pm CT
Posted by: A Field's Fan
The latest edition of the Windy City Times dated 9/3/08 has a nice ad on page 6 for our protest rally and book signing next Tuesday.
The ad is on the same page as the continuation of the cover story on Barrack Obama so it should be seen by lots of people!
Date: Wed, September 3, 2008 9:37 pm CT
Posted by: JamesfromCa
I own the book Marshall Field's Food and Fashion, love the book I only wish the author gave me more, more photos, more recipes, more architecture, graphic design, store design and merchandising, more historical photos. Perhaps May Co. or Federated didn't give out much information to the author and she worked with what she was given. I would love to see a large scale book with more in depth info but at this point I doubt that macy's would hand over any archival anything that celebrates Field's. Overall it's a cute book to go along with my other Field's ephemera that's in my collection.
Date: Wed, September 3, 2008 5:33 pm CT
Posted by: gle
Messy's is announcing an exclusive alliance with Tommy Hilfiger to commence on September 9, as noted in this Associated Press article in the "Tribune" (comment blog included).
"Macy's to launch exclusive alliance with Tommy Hilfiger in men's, women's sportswear"
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/sns-ap-macys-tommy-hilfiger,0,2685091.story
I will be OUTSIDE the store September 9 with the many other Field's Fans at our Noontime rally, not even thinking about Hilfiger.
Letters to the "Tribune" can be sent to ctc-TribLetter@tribune.com
Date: Wed, September 3, 2008 3:23 pm CT
Posted by: JH
i dont live in Chicago but i know what your feeling we lost our local store here in Pittsburgh it was Kaufmann's it had a clock on its corner to it was goldleaf and to pittsburgh it was just as important as Marshall Field's i really like what you are doing its great to bring back beloved names that we have grown up=2 0with. But the people in pittsburgh are not as motivated to save kaufmann's as you guys are to save marshall field's! i do what i can to support kaufmann's i have sent letters asking to just rename the flagship(no response) but to do what i can i just dont shop at macy's.
Date: Wed, September 3, 2008 3:17 pm CT
Posted by: gle
As I went by the State Street store today, I touched the plaque as usual. A woman yelled, "So you want your Marshall Field's too!" She said she was one of the employees who got laid off from the warehouse. She worked for Field's for many years and is not happy with what Messy's has done to the store. I gave her our information and told her about our September 9 events. She said God bless us and wished us all the best!
Inside the store, the fur coats have disappeared and there are construction curtains in their place. There seem to be ladders and construction stuff all over the place (they stand out more than the merchandise). I hope something actually gets fixed. The clock at State and Randolph has the wrong time again.
I gave out several leaflets today. People are rooting for our September 9 rally at Noon and book signing reception at 5:00 p.m.
Date: Wed, September 3, 2008 12:06 pm CT
Posted by: Jimmy Gimbels
It's been just your run-of-the-mill week for Jimmy Gimbels. Sold my house (in two weeks!) and found a new place in three days! So my life is madly packing for the move next week. In the past, a new home meant new linens, towels and furniture...usually purchased from Marshall Field's. Not anymore. Maybe what my new place needs is several Martha Stewart place settings...or perhaps Club Room towels. Ick. No way. Not one penney spent at Macy's...EVER!
After all, look how well the Fieldcrest towels have stood up and the timeless designs of the furniture look as great as the day that green truck pulled into the driveway. While packing for the move, I realized that most of my home furnishings were from Marshall Field's. The great service. The great selection. The attention to quality. Oh, how I miss it more than ever before.
Field's IS worth fighting for!
Keep handing our buttons.
Distribute flyers.
Write letters to newspapers, magazines and TV stations.
Marshall Field's forever!
Date: Tues, September 2, 2008 11:59 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay
-------------------------------------------------------
FieldsFansChicago.org
Newsletter Number 16
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 2, 2008
-------------------------------------------------------
In just one week...
-----------------------
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2008
Two Very Special Events in Support of
THE RETURN OF MARSHALL FIELD'S
12:10-1:00 pm
LUNCH HOUR RALLY
5:00-8:00 pm
INFORMAL RECEPTION, TALK & BOOK SIGNING
...featuring...
Joan Greene, Author:
Marshall Field's Food and Fashion: A Chicago Tradition
-----------------------
Other topics in this Newsletter
* HAVE YOU RSVP'D YET for OUR EVENING TALK & BOOK SIGNING?
* BRING YOUR SISTER! BRING YOUR CO-WORKERS! BRING YOUR COUSIN!
* FREE "I WANT MY MARSHALL FIELD'S" BUTTONS
* PRINT & DISTRIBUTE LEAFLETS
* IF YOU SEE SOMETHING, WRITE SOMETHING!
* PLEASE SPONSOR OUR ACTIVITIES
* STAY IN TOUCH VIA THE FIELDSFANSCHICAGO.ORG BLOG
* SPECIAL REGARDS
* HOW TO SUBSCRIBE& UNSUBSCRIBE; MORE..
-------------------------------------------------------
PLEASE HELP BY FORWARDING THIS NEWSLETTER ON
TO ALL POTENTIALLY INTERESTED FRIENDS & FAMILY.
-------------------------------------------------------
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2008
LUNCH HOUR RALLY IN SUPPORT OF FIELD'S!
12:10--1:00 pm Under the Great Clock at
STATE & WASHINGTON STREETS
-----------------------
* Field's Fans should start gathering at Noon
Under the Great Marshall Field's Clock at
State & Washington Streets
* Wear your "Marshall Field's Best" or something
dark green (please, no profane t-shirts).
* Bring signs and placards with Marshall Field's slogans.
* A limited number of additional signs will be available at the protest.
* Carry a Marshall Field's Shopping Bag.
* Carry a City of Chicago Flag.
* Please be peaceable and dignified in the spirit of Marshall Field's.
* Please be careful not to obstruct the doors to the store.
* Please do not stand in or block the street.
* Check http://www.FieldsFansChicago.org and your Email box
for last minute news and bulletins.
-------------------------------------------------------
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2008
A SPECIAL TALK & BOOK SIGNING
MARSHALL FIELD'S FOOD & FASHION: A CHICAGO TRADITION
by Author Joan Greene
5:00--8:00 pm
Location within walking distance of State and Washington
RSVP in advance for exact location and other details
-----------------------
PLEASE NOTE: SPACE IS VERY LIMITED FOR THIS EVENT.
RSVP AS SOON AS POSSIBLE TO ENSURE ADMITTANCE
EMAIL RSVP@FieldsFansChicago.org or call 312.662.8980.
===============
An excerpt from Joan Greene's Marshall Field's Food and Fashion: A Chicago Tradition:
"Field's is a department store renowned for the profusion and quality of its goods,
its gracious ambience, and superb customer service. . . . A visit to Chicago would
not be complete without a visit to Marshall Field's on State Street. The store has
weathered destruction by fire not once but twice, the Civil War and two world wars,
and the Great Depression, becoming an emblem of the city of Chicago, and the standard
by which retail is measured--or should be measured. . . . To Chicagoans,
Marshall Field and Company is a civic prize and a symbol of the city at its best."
===============
On Tuesday, September 9, 2008, all are invited to participate in a very special evening celebrating Marshall Field's, reminding the world why Chicago's icon must be restored.
The evening will begin with light refreshments at 5:00 pm.
At 5:30 pm, there will be a very special talk by Joan Greene, author of Marshall Field's Food and Fashion: A Chicago Tradition. Ms. Greene offers an expansive perspective that is both historical as well as forward-looking, covering the international importance of Field's from its early fashion and customer service innovations to Mrs. Hering's pot pies and Frango mints, to recent innovations such as Marshall Field's 2003 vertical fashion show and more. Afterwards, representatives from FieldsFansChicago.org will present an overview of the grassroots organization's ongoing efforts to bring back Marshall Field's. Questions and discussion with the participants, moderated by Jim McKay of FieldsFansChicago.org, will conclude this portion of the evening.
From 6:30 to 8:00 pm, Ms. Greene will sign copies of her book, Marshall Field's Food and Fashion: A Chicago Tradition (Pomegranate, 2005). Copies of this book will be available for purchase at this event.
Please remember: Space is very limited for this event. Please R.S.V.P. as soon as possible while space remains to ensure admittance. R.S.V.P. via email at rsvp@fieldsfanschicago.org or phone at 312.662.8980.
-------------------------------------------------------
HAVE YOU RSVP'D YET for OUR EVENING TALK & BOOK SIGNING?
We hope you can attend the very special Tuesday evening event with Joan Greene, author of Marshall Field's Food & Fashion: A Chicago Tradition. Due to space constraints and the generous donation of refreshments, we ask that you RSVP in advance so we can plan accordingly and accommodate you and any one you wish to bring.
Please RSVP for our Tuesday evening event by emailing RSVP@FieldsFansChicago.org or phoning (312) 662-8980 today!
We hope you will attend this event! Please let us know in advance if you plan to attend!
-------------------------------------------------------
BRING YOUR SISTER! BRING YOUR CO-WORKERS! BRING YOUR COUSIN!
Bring your brother, your guru, your fitness trainer, your hair stylist, your dog groomer!
Bring your bridge partner, your favorite waitress from your favorite restaurant, your rabbi, your priest, your dentist!
Just bring someone to the Tuesday, September 9, 2009 Lunch Hour Rally on State Street or the Evening Presentation & Book Signing Event!
Just be there and be sure to bring someone--or two, or three, or more!
We need as many people as possible! Everybody loves Marshall Field's! So be sure to come--and be sure to bring someone!
-------------------------------------------------------
FREE "I WANT MY MARSHALL FIELD'S" BUTTONS
One way that Field's Fans can help is wearing and displaying special items in support of bringing back our Marshall Field's.
Reprising one of our 2006 slogans, "I Want My Marshall Field's" buttons are back! Thanks to Alfred, Jim and especially Gail, free "I Want My Marshall Field's" buttons will be distributed to all who attend the Tuesday, September 9, 2008 events. Be there and be sure to get yours!
-------------------------------------------------------
Get Out The Word!
PRINT & DISTRIBUTE LEAFLETS
Spreading the word how Field's can come back is easy! Now you can download Adobe Acrobat PDF files to print your own leaflets
Pass out leaflets-the same kind that are passed out under the Field's clock at State and Washington-at any place it is permissible in the public way. (Please note this excludes many private malls.)
Print and carry some with you or in your car. You can hang them anywhere you find community bulletin boards-your apartment building, coffee houses, student unions at universities, laundries, your country club, church,...the possibilities are endless. And of course, be sure to hang one on the front door or window of your home or business!
Please see http://fieldsfanschicago.org/leaflets.html for more details including links to download the files and instructions to print your own leaflets that help bring back Marshall Field's!
-------------------------------------------------------
IF YOU SEE SOMETHING, WRITE SOMETHING!
As a Field's Fan, you can help bring back Marshall Field's. We Field's Fans make a difference by keeping Field's in the public eye. When Macy's inevitably fails in the Chicago area, we don't want it to be glossed over as if it was simply about sales figures.
Please let newspapers, television, radio, web media, blogs, news comment boards, and public officials know that both the public and the private good is best served when Marshall Field's is restored to 111 North State Street.
When you see ANY story in the newspaper, on television, or on the web about Field's, it is essential to respond--even if you think the story is favorable towards the return of Field's. People need to be reminded that these stores have slipped so much because they are no longer Marshall Field's and they can only be brought back up by being restored as Marshall Field's stores.
These suggestions are made for responding to media articles or TV news segments:
* If responding to web-based blogs, bulletin boards, or news comments areas, please remember to keep a copy of your post in case it is lost or deleted.
* If submitting a "Letter to the Editor" by the internet, send it in a standard email message. If replying via web-based form, remember to cut-and-copy the contents for your own records. If you submit via email, you have the opportunity to cc: or bcc: a copy to yourself--submitting via other methods on the internet means you probably won't have a dated copy of your response, if you get a copy at all. It is very important that you keep a copy for your records.
* The Letters to the Sun-Times should be sent to: letters@suntimes.com
* The Letters to the Tribune should be sent to: ctc-TribLetter@tribune.com
* The Letters Chicago Tribune Magazine should be sent to: TribMag@tribune.com
* The Letters to Crain's Chicago Business should be sent to: letters@chicagobusiness.com.
* If submitting by US Mail, make a photocopy of your letter.
* Please remember to include a daytime phone number for verification purposes.
* Be certain to indicate in your letter that it is "for publication."
* Remember, items submitted to the "Letters to the Editor" section should not be cross-posted to other forums like the fieldsfanschicago.org blog. The publications request exclusivity.
* Be succinct as possible. Longer items don't have as much of a chance of being published. While there are many facets to the loss of Field's, consider focusing on just one or two facets that will best help the larger cause.
* Even if your letter does not get published in print or web media, remember that the media takes note of the public's pulse. Every letter reminds editors and producers that this is still indeed a very important issue.
-------------------------------------------------------
PLEASE SPONSOR OUR ACTIVITIES
Please help finance our special evening on September 9, our ongoing leaflet and button distributions, and other activities in support of Field's.
We are totally committed to continuing our efforts. People have come forward in amazing ways to help, donating leaflets, pin-on buttons, bumper stickers, advertising and more.
We need your help so we can continue to inspire others to support the return of Marshall Field's.
If you can donate, please email donate@fieldsfanschicago.org.
All contributions are solely channeled to offset our activities.
-------------------------------------------------------
STAY IN TOUCH VIA THE FIELDSFANSCHICAGO.ORG BLOG
The FieldsFansChicago.org blog is a place for Field's Fans to talk about Marshall Field's and what it means to them. Stop on by to share thoughts, comments, news and rumors. The URL is http://www.fieldsfanschicago.org/blog
-------------------------------------------------------
SPECIAL REGARDS
Marshall Field's CAN come back. AT&T Wireless became Cingular but then came back as AT&T. On the west coast, the hugely popular Lucky Supermarket chain came back with 75 stores after a seven year absence. The Ford Taurus was revived after a multi-year absence. The recent revival of Lord and Taylor as well as Von Maur's plans to open two more Chicago-area stores show that there is a market for quality stores like Marshall Field's, despite the challenging economy.
Your ongoing support and dedication is what enables our progress to continue. It is the work of we Field's Fans that reminds key business and civic leaders that that these stores can be an overwhelming success again as Marshall Fields.
Our efforts are so essential because it gives immense consciousness to the once and future Chicago institution, Marshall Field's.
Remember, your efforts to help bring back Field's are greatly appreciated, respected and admired. You are helping to make history!
-------------------------------------------------------
HOW TO SUBSCRIBE & UNSUBSCRIBE; MORE...
TO UNSUBSCRIBE:
Send email to unsubscribe@fieldsfanschicago.org
Please include the email address you wish unsubscribed if it is not the one from which you are sending the request.
TO SUBSCRIBE:
Send email to subscribe@fieldsfanschicago.org
Subscription requests must be sent from the email address that is to be added to the subscriber list.
SWITCHING ADDRESSES?
1.) Send an unsubscribe request from either you old address or your new one; then
2.) send a subscribe request from your new address.
Again, NEW "Subscribe" requests MUST come from the address at which this newsletter is to be delivered.
* Please send all bug reports to jjmckay@fieldsfanschicago.org
* This newsletter and the activities and events described within have NO affiliation with Macy's, Inc., Federated Department Stores, May Department Stores, Macy's, Bloomingdale's, Marshall Field's, the Field Family, the Field Foundation of Chicago, keepitfields.org, etc., and the views, opinions and info expressed here represent only the writer.
-------------------------------------------------------
END OF NEWSLETTER #16
-------------------------------------------------------
Date: Tues, September 2, 2008 11:58 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKay
FIELDSFANSCHICAGO.ORG ANNOUNCES TWO EVENTS on TUES., SEPT. 9, 2008
IN SUPPORT OF THE RETURN OF CHICAGO'S MARSHALL FIELD'S:
A LUNCH HOUR PROTEST RALLY & AN EVENING TALK/BOOK SIGNING
(CHICAGO--September 2, 2008)
What: LUNCH HOUR PROTEST RALLY in support of the return of Marshall Field's.
Where: "Under the Great Clock" at the corner of State & Washington Sts, Chicago.
When: 12:10 PM until 1:00 PM on TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2008.
======ALSO======
What: Marshall Field's Food & Fashion: A Chicago Tradition:
TALK & BOOK SIGNING by Author Joan Greene.
Where: Location TBA near State & Washington Sts. Call 312.662.8980 for Details.
When: 5:30 PM on TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2008.
On Sat., Sept. 9, 2006. all "Marshall Field's" stores were converted to "Macy's," including the iconic Marshall Field's flagship store on State Street. On that very sad day, hundreds of Field's supporters converged at State and Washington under the Great Marshall Field's clock to demonstrate that Chicago--indeed, the world--wants Marshall Field's, not Macy's. Several protest rallies have since been held under the Great Clock including our largest featuring over 300 participants on Sun., Sept. 9, 2007. Although in 2008 the anniversary falls on a weekday, Fieldb s loyalists will convene during lunch hour to mark two years since the loss of Field's.
For the past two years, a grassroots boycott has been in effect against Macy's and Bloomingdale's stores. Sales are down significantly overall at these stores since the conversions of stores from Marshall Field's to Macy's. Field's supporters maintain that the boycott is working. Contrary to Macyb s promises, the change from Field's has been much more than simply a name change. Numerous tourists have noted they no longer have a good reason to come to Chicago to shop because there are Macyb s everywhere across the U.SA. and it is not uniquely Chicago. Many customers have commented that Macy's merchandise and service does not measure up overall to what was offered at Marshall Field's.
Since last fall, Field's Fans have so far distributed over 111,000 leaflets on State Street, at civic events and elsewhere reminding Chicagoans that Field's can indeed come back as the result of a sustained customer boycott of Macy's. Over 105,000 lapel stickers and pin-on buttons that say "Keep It Marshall Field's," "Marshall Field's Forever, " and "I Want My Marshall Field's" have been distributed to Field's Fans worldwide. Thousands of bumper stickers that say "Field's Is Chicago/Boycott Macy's" have also been distributed. These activities have received international media attention, with coverage by Reuters, AP, Chicago Tribune, Chicago Sun-Times, The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, New York Post, CBS Sunday Morning, WGN, NPR, Chicago Public Radio, the local and national television news reports of ABC, CBS, FOX, and NBC, and more.
In May 2008, a contingency of Field's supporters attended Macy's, Inc. annual shareholders meeting in Cincinnati, confronting Macy's CEO Terry Lundgren, imploring him to bring back Chicago's Marshall Field's.
FieldsFansChicago.org organizers steadfastly maintain, "Marshall Field's CAN come back. AT&T Wireless became Cingular but then came back as AT&T. On the West Coast, the hugely popular Lucky Supermarket chain came back with 75 stores after a seven-year absence. The Ford Taurus was revived after a multi-year absence. The recent revival of Lord and Taylor as well as Von Maur's plans to open two more Chicago-area stores show quality department stores like Marshall Field's can do well despite the challenging economy. With the widespread perception that Marshall Field's loss is a huge corporate blunder, we look unflinchingly to the future and keep emphasizing that although Field's is gone for now, it can indeed come back--just as Coke did when consumers rejected New Coke. It is only a matter of time.
For further information, email jjmckay@fieldsfanschicago.org or phone 312.662.8980.
V.1.0w
-30-
Date: Tues, September 2, 2008 7:34 pm CT
Posted by: EricA fellow co-worker and I asked my boss if we could have an extra extended lunch hour for next Tuesday's protest on State.
Not only did my boss say OK, she said she would join us!
You might try the same thing with your boss!
See you under the clock.
Date: Tues, September 2, 2008 2:04 am CT
Posted by: MaryI want Marshall Field's Back! Macy's does not compare!Date: Mon, September 1, 2008 12:34 pm CT
Posted by: Jim McKayRegarding the posts about Carson's parent Bon-Ton having some of its stores picked up by Macy's: I am very skeptical at this point. To be sure, Bon-Ton hasn't been doing well at all in parts of the Northeastern US and its stock is worth roughly 8% of what it was a year and half ago. But unless Bon-Ton goes Chapter 11 (a possibility), Macy's isn't going to be interested in assuming so much of Bon-Ton. For now, I think the original post is just a red hering.Date: Mon, September 1, 2008 11:45 am CT
Posted by: Judy M.I just read the second most horrible thing (after Messy's doing away with Field's)!! Now CARSON'S is a target?!?? Are they just trying to "stick it" to Chicago or are they just stupid???? Messy's can't even attract customer's to the stores that used to be Field's. How can they think we'd be more inclined to shop at stores that used to be Carson's??? Just imagine - a Messy's on every corner! Two or more at every mall!!! I feel like I'm living the "Invasion of the Department Store Snatchers" scenario! Are they envisioning mindless zombies filing endlessly into their stores simply because that's all we have? This has to stop.. NOW.. I'd rather shop at the Salvation Army store than Messy's (I'd probably find a better selection!). Makes me think about that big red star they use as their logo....and what they're really all about.
See you all on September 9!! Long live Marshall Field's!!!
Judy
Date: Sun, August 31, 2008 9:34 pm CT
Posted by: JoelI noticed a tourist map for sale at Walgreens. It is copyright 2007. It shows the block at 111 N State as "Marshall Field's Building (Macy's)".
There's also a set of 50 cards that each have maps of routes for short architectural tours. The maps covering the area where 111 N State is located. All the other buildings are named on the map, but 111 N State is explained in a sort of asterisked way, saying Chicago is sad that Marshall Field's is Macy's.
Date: Sun, August 31, 2008 5:45 pm CT
Posted by: DonaldRe: what you are doing to bring back Field's. Love it, Love it, Love it!Date: Sun, August 31, 2008 3:23 pm CT
Posted by: MrS, OKCWe have Macy's here (Oklahoma City) and they are terrible! I am from Chicago and would love to see Fields back!Date: Sun, August 31, 2008 2:34 pm CT
Posted by: PeterThese days the windows on State Street are a bunch of gigantic flat panel TVs. Like one should come all the way down to State Street to look at TV sets with ads.
The State Street store is one of a kind asset that Macy's is clueless as to how to use to its advantage. They would be better off if they let someone else use it and captitalize on the great resource it is.
Date: Sun, August 31, 2008 11:35 am CT
Posted by: Jim McKayThanks to all of those who helped make leafleting on State Street possible yesterday afternoon. Hundreds of leaflets promoting our dual rally and book signing events on September 9 were passed out under the Great Clock at State and Washington. Since we started doing this in fall 2006, it was not uncommon to encounter someone every now and then who was vocally not supportive of our cause. In the past week, there's been three leafleting sessions. While there are those who decline our leaflets, I've yet to encounter any such disagreement with our cause. Also, we appear to be gaining support from those who have tried Macy's but now won't shop at the store until it is Field's again.
If you wish to help distribute our leaflets this week in promotion of our 9/9 events, please email me privately at jjmckay@fieldsfanschicago.org Thank you.
Date: Sat, August 30, 2008 11:35 am CT
Posted by: JoelThere's a sister book to the Joan Greene Book, Marshall Field's Food and Fashion. It is by Jay Pridmore and is the perfect companion to Joan's book since it talks about Architecture at Field's. There are other books in this series on Chicago Architecture, but Field's is the only entity that has TWO books!Date: Sat, August 30, 2008 10:12 am CT
Posted by: Debbie BI have not set foot in a Macy's store since the name changed in Sept. 2006 and don't intend to. There are too many other retail choices in Chicago and suburb, Macy's...who needs them?Bring Field's back and I'll be back too.
Date: Sat, August 30, 2008 8:01 am CT
Posted by: RonRegarding the post rumoring the takeover of Carson's by Macy's, I think it is nothing more than a rumor at this point. Carson's parent would have to go under. Carson's in this area seems to be doing quite well. It's parent Bon-ton's out East stores that are faltering, if you ask me. Bon-ton's real problem is that it has to pay a lot of interest on loans, it's not that the stores are doing so badly. One has to ask as to what circumstances Macy's would want to get involved with that.
Still, I think the Carson's of the past five or six years is much more similar to Macy's than Field's. And remember, in more than a few markets, Macy's doesn't stop at acquiring and converting just one department store brand. In Boston, they took over Jordan Marsh and then took over Filene's. In LA, Seattle, NYC, Philly and elsewhere, they also took over more than one chain, usually taking out the more competitive of the two chains first.
So while I have some skepticism, don't think it's not possible that Carson's could become Macy's at some point too.
Date: Fri, August 29, 2008 10:35 pm CT
Posted by: JakeEnough is enough. Close the friggin Macy's stores and sell the real estate and Marshall Field brand to a company that will value all it's real potential. I can't believe Macy's management doesn't understand the Marshall Field jewel - especially the windfall they could have in Chicago. The Marshall Field name, quality, and service mean too much to ignore in this economic environment. It's too easy for Macy's to deny it and continue their merry way of selling crappy China made goods using 18 year old high school drop outs. We know better. Time will tell - actually, it's already showing.Date: Fri, August 29, 2008 5:23 pm CT
Posted by: PeteGood to see the sept. 9 rally get a mention in today's Tribune.
And Regarding the Tribune business item today about Frank Guzetta unretiring to Ralph Lauren. It was a scant 8 months earlier or less that he was talking about his three year plan for Macy's to successfully replace Field's. He only made it to 1.5 years.
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/chi-fri-notebook-retail-guzzettaa ug29,0,4014274.story
Sorry, seems like Terry Lundgren made him the fall guy for his idiotic choice to kill off his best brand, Marshall Field's. How could anyone succeed after such a dumb premise?
While I don't get why some feel Guzetta was so wonderful--afterall, he only presided over Daytons/Hudsons/Fields for 20 months, only four of which was without Lundgren's rule.
Date: Fri, August 29, 2008 4:16 pm CT
Posted by: JoyceA couple of days ago I was in our local Messys in Carbondale. Remember, we have extremely limited options here in Carbondale. Anyway, I start taking some samples of skin care lotions from the cosmetic counter, like I've done in the past. Suddenly, I get confronted and verbally attacked by some snooty, young cosmetic counter girl, who tells me shes seen me there before, and I can't take samples of their expensive serums, because they're too expensive! It was very embarrassing, as they treated me like a criminal. I remember at Marshall Fields, the cosmetic people would offer all sorts of samples. I thought about contacting the store manager and I might, but given that its Messy's, I don't expect much positive response, because they don't seem to care about their customers. The whole experience really reminded me of how much I miss Marshall Field's in my life.Date: Fri, August 29, 2008 11:23 am CT
Posted by: ChrisI received the e-mail newsletter recently. I'm glad to see things are still going. It's awfully hard to sustain such efforts, even for a cause like Marshall Field's. It says a lot about the cause and what you people do.
I look forward to being part of the rally and also meeting Joan Greene. I purchased her book at the Chicago Architecture center on Michigan Avenue where it seems to be very popular.
Does anyone know if Miss Greene was a former employee? I hope other former Field's employees that I miss also attend.
Date: Fri, August 29, 2008 9:16 am CT
Posted by: gleField's Fans' September 9 rally has coverage as part of today's "Tribune" article about Messy's former Frank Guzetta and his new career at Ralph Lauren:
"Macy's exec makes Lauren new home" inside retailing by Sandra M. Jones
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/chi-fri-notebook-retail-guzzettaaug29,0,4014274.story
There is a comment blog. Letters can be sent to the "Tribune" at ctc-TribLetter@tribune.com and smjones@tribune.com.
Date: Thurs, August 28, 2008 9:30 pm CT
Posted by: Daniel W. Harcourt IIFieldsfans,
I passed by a Macy's store the other evening-I won't mention which one on purpose-and found it very humorous that most of the lights which illuminate the store's name were out. On one side of the building, only the 'y' was lit which caused me to immediately question again Why did they think that they could take away 'My Marshall Field's'? In a lousy economy, Macy's has deliberately alienated a VERY loyal customer base which directly results in reduced earnings. They can lie all they want about how great and solid the company is, we all know the truth! On another side of the building only the 'Mac' was lit which reminded me of how similar Macy's is to McDonalds. Don't get me wrong, McDonalds is a fine fast food restaurant. I would never, however, celebrate an important event by going to McDonalds. McDonalds philosophy is that the customer should be able to go into any McDonalds and order food which tastes exactly the same at every restaurant-a similar concept to that Macy's provides. Marshall Field's, on the other hand, was very special. People looked forward to receiving gifts in boxes with the Marshall Field's name on them. Frango Mints were gifts many many Chicagoan's sent out to friends and famiy during the holidays to those not living near a Marshall Field's store. Just walking into a Marshall Field's store for many people lifted their spirits and encouraged them to spend money. I can't list the number of times I went into a Marshall Field's store to simply 'look around' and ended up spending well more than I would ever have imagined-several times in the thousands of dollars. At least the Macy's conversion of the Marshall Field's stores has saved me money on impulse buying. I still want my Marshall Field's back though. Macy's will never hold a candle to my Marshall Field's.
Daniel W. Harcourt II
Schaumburg, ILDate: Thurs, August 28, 2008 9:19 pm CT
Posted by: Richard in HoustonI note Belk and Macy's are rumored to be teaming up for the purchase of Dillards. It would be my hope that Belk would take the Texas stores since they have a very minor presence here. I have only come across some in small towns in my travels. In my opinion, they would really have to step up to the plate to bring their merchandise up to be on par with the Dillards in Houston. Especially those stores in the wealthier suburbs and The Galleria.
It amazes me what has happened in the last 30 years. I have a book called "The Grand Emporiums" that was printed in the early 1980s. It chronicles the nations department stores by region with excellent historical documentation. There were literally thousands of stores. I remember reading men's fashion magazines in the 1980s which, at that time, had a location within the magazine that one could turn to that referenced the stores that the merchandise featured was available at. There were scores of stores then. Now there are just a handful. It is a real shame. No competition. No selection. No personality. No glamour. The consumer really lost out on that one.
Date: Thurs, August 28, 2008 5:41 pm CT
Posted by: Jeff S.A gal at the Fox Valley Store tells me that the Christmas Department will be open September 14th there on the lower level. I wonder what marvels we will see this year? Am sure it will be loaded with "Martha"!! (Probably duplicated at Wal-Mart, K-Mart, Target and Sears!) Also, at the Joliet Store; the down escalator appears to be working -- and yet the "broken escalator" signage is simply pushed to the side; not put away in a back room which would be proper.Date: Thurs, August 28, 2008 4:09 pm CT
Posted by: GayleI drove past the Oak Brook Home Store last night about 7:00, and there was NOT ONE CAR in front of the building! At first I thought maybe they'd changed the hours and closed early, but I noticed cars near the back of the building where employees park, and all interior and exterior lights were on. I'm sure Thursday nights aren't the busiest nights for furniture shoppers, but when it was Field's there were ALWAYS several cars in the lot. I can't imagine how they can afford to keep the doors open. Don't imagine they will much longer!Date: Thurs, August 28, 2008 2:17 pm CT
Posted by: ZeldaHi Field's Fans!
Well, "those wacky folks at Macy's" have done it again, trying to sell last year's fur coats on a hot day in August for 50% off (the same coats that were on sale last February for 60% off! What do they take us for?
On a more serious note, the Environmental Protection Agency has fined Macy's %50,000 for throwing out mercury-based light bulbs in their regular trash. This news is right up there with the fruit fly infestation of 2007! These people have no respect for the environment, whether it involves foisting toxic waste in regular garbage cans, preparing food in the midst of an infestation or keeping up the shopping environment of a formerly World Class store.
Is this what they call successful retailing?
NO WAY, NO HOW, NO MACY'S!
Your Friend in Field's,
Zelda
Date: Thurs, August 28, 2008 12:01 pm CT
Posted by: JimSteve--thanks for the heads up on those rumors. Some of been discussed but not in months. Would it be possible to be more specific to identify where you heard or saw that? Thanks.Date: Thurs, August 28, 2008 7:05 pm CT
Posted by: SteveRumors are flying that Macy's and Belk are teaming up to purchase Dillard's and split the locations up. Dillard's lost about $55 million 2nd quarter (before a gain on the sale of a private plane). Also, Bon-Ton is rumored to be only only weeks away from filing bankrupcy after losing $34 million 2nd quarter alone. A similar Macy's/Belk scenario has Macy's getting their stores in Michigan and from Indiana westward. Only about 1/3 of the Carson stores in Chicago will remain open as Macy's. The coming weeks should be very interesting!Date: Wed, August 27, 2008 10:08 pm CT
Posted by: SteveCTO Drew
ThE Philadelphia area was a special retail environment prior to 1986. They had John Wanamaker, Strawbridge's, Gimbels, Bloomingdale's, Bamburgers, Abraham & Strauss, and B. Altman along with Lord & Taylor, Saks and Bonwit Teller. What a great shopping experience that would have been. However market forces came into play, Gimbels was shuttered, along with B'.Altman, Bonwits and John Wanamaker due to their parent companies. May Company tried to replace Wanamaker with Hecht's, but then bought Strawbridges's and raped that store into a shadow of what it once was before Macy's closed it and moved to the great Wanamaker's building which also was raped and consolidated into a tiny fraction of what it was by MAy.
Los Angeles too had some great reatil stores Robinson's, MAy Co, Bullock's, Bullock's Wilshire, I. Magnin, The Brodway, Saks, Nordstrom . However the same forces came into play and slowly one by one was closed or consolidated into another division. Broadway became Macy's along with Bullock's and Robinsion's was consolidated with May Co, to eventually become a May Co. clone. FDS closed I. Magnin and consloidated Bullock's into Macy's that took over the ailing poorly run Broadway stores.
Date: Wed, August 27, 2008 9:24 pm CT
Posted by: RonaldI pass Old Orchard Messy today and the store was not busy and were more employee than shopper. Why Messy bring back the Marshall Field name to Chicago and I will shop there! Thank youDate: Wed, August 27, 2008 3:27 pm CT
Posted by: gleCalling all cheapskates: Messy's has fur coats on sale at 25% to 50% off. There are rows and rows of them in all sorts of "unusual" styles and colors. You can't miss 'em--they put them so you almost run smack into them if you enter the store on the Randolph and Wabash side.
But don't go in the Randolph door closest to State Street. There are couple of buckets, a barricade sign and some rust colored slop on the floor there.
Moving on towards State Street, "pardon our appearance" signs are in the window with the announcement about Macy's magic about to happen.
The cobwebs were still on the Marshall Field's nameplate on State by Randolph. I tried to dust them a little, but they are higher up than I realized. I could only reach the bottom edge of the plate.
And that's the eyewitness account from State and Randolph on this Wednesday afternoon August 27, 2008.
Date: Wed, August 27, 2008 10:28 am CT
Posted by: M.L., New YorkI was so happy to have stumbled upon your website today, and quite pleased to read about the activities of Fields Fans Chicago! I grew up in Northern Indiana and a shopping trip to Marshall Fields was always the greatest of treats.
I'm writing about the Save Fields rally on September 9th, and wondering if it might be something east-coasters could also hold at the 34th Street store in N.Y.C. If there are other New Yorkers, I would be glad to pass out Save Fields material and wear a button September 9th on 34th street.
Date: Wed, August 27, 2008 10:06 am CT
Posted by: M.L., New YorkI will always have special memories of the grandeur of Marshall Fields. Currently I am living north of N.Y.C. and the Macy's at Herald Square is a DUMP! To classify Marshall Fields as a Macy's is an abomination. I plan to wear one of your buttons on my next visit to the city. Keep up the fight!Date: Tues, August 26, 2008 8:34 pm CT
Posted by: A Field's FanThe September issue of Chicago Magazine (with Mayor Daley on the cover) features a special fasion supplement with ads from all sorts of department stores. Macy's has an ad in the main mag as well as the fashion supplement. How they can have the gall to use that 150 years banner in Chicago magazine is beyond me. It's an insult to Chicago.Date: Tues, August 26, 2008 8:23 pm CT
Posted by: MaryI was passing through Old Orchard in the store that once was Field's. I decided to stop and see what the prices for frangos were. Besides apparently charging a dollar more the experation dates on many of the boxes are just a few weeks away. That never happened at Field's. And Oh yes, they still have the upside down image of the Field's clock on the back. Clueless those Macy's people are.Date: Tues, August 26, 2008 1:02 pm CT
Posted by: Rosa TowsendI received a bookmark about this site and the book signing and rally on State Street last night. Keep up the good cause for Chicago's Field's!Date: Tues, August 26, 2008 8:22 am CT
Posted by: PeteToday's SunTimes has a review of last Friday's Glamorama. You can leave comments at the end. You can also email the editor at letters@suntimes.com
http://www.suntimes.com/entertainment/people/1126751,CST-FTR-Glam26.articleDate: Mon, August 25, 2008 10:21 pm CT
Posted by: John HamiltonPlease don't give up! I was so disappointed to visit Chicago and see only vague remnants of the originality that was Marshall Field's... I hate Macy's! Macy's sucks!!!!You guys are the best!
Date: Mon, August 25, 2008 9:38 pm CT
Posted by: Mike MI will see you all there on September 9th!!Date: Mon, August 25, 2008 3:49 pm CT
Posted by: JLMarshall Fields is a Chicago institution!Date: Mon, August 25, 2008 2:34 pm CT
Posted by: PeterThe Sun Times News Group's neigborhood paper for Norridge and Hardwood Heights had a review of Glamorama. The fact that this is pretty much irrelevant to the two suburbs that are 15 miles away shows you the lengths to which the sun-times will go to suck up to Macy's for advertising revenues. The readers have the last word though. You can leave comments afterwards. No Password or login is needed to post.
The URL Is http://blogs.pioneerlocal.com/entertainment/2008/08/a_night_at_macys_glamorama_cin.html
Date: Mon, August 25, 2008 1:01 pm CT
Posted by: A Field's FanVisionary Field's Marketing exec Charles Weston Folds, has died at age 97. He was connected with everything from Frangos to Louis Vuitton introductions at Field's
Full article in the Sun-Times today at:
http://www.suntimes.com/news/obituaries/1124711,CST-NWS-xfolds25.articleDate: Sun, August 24, 2008 5:23 pm CT
Posted by: Da BurghMany of the comments have been critical of The Red Star Glamorama focusing on 1980s style and trends. Just remember that the "fashion" merchandise sold in The Red Star Store IS the 1980s!
As I walked through the men's department of The Red Star in a Pittsburgh area mall, I thought I was back in Horne's or Kaufmann's circa 1987--big display of Polo in the familiar blue surroundings, Nautica with the "nautical" motif and, of course, the ever-popular Tommy Hilfiger! I swear the Tommy clothing was exactly the same style and design everyone wore about 20 years ago!
No doubt Mr Lunkgreed was able to find some old display charts to enable him to save a few bucks in preparing these "designer shops."
The bright lights, loud music, has-been fashions, Martha Stewart home goods combine to create a most unique shopping atmosphere.
Date: Sun, August 24, 2008 12:39 pm CT
Posted by: MattIn response to John, I would also like to know if anyone has heard the "Theme" of the Christmas windows. As I started after the last holiday season and the termination of the woman who did the windows for 20+ years, I wouldn't be surprised if the Commie Store didn't even have them.
Watching this company go out of business is like watching a train wreck. You hate to see it, but you can't help but look.
Date: Sat, August 23, 2008 3:58 pm CT
Posted by: LGHI'm from the southwest burbs. When my family and I visited State Street, it just wasnt the same walking into Macy's. I want my kids to experience Marshall Fields--Macy's isnt' the same. We want Field's back!Date: Sat, August 23, 2008 12:09 pm CT
Posted by: PeteWhatever happened to Frango Shower Gel? Remember, Terry Lundgren introduced it at a November 2006 press conference to show Macy's was keeping up Field's traditions. Like he gets it at all! Frango shower gel, clearly the way to satiate those who miss Marshall Field's. NOT!Date: Sat, August 23, 2008 9:01 pm CT
Posted by: Ruth150 years of Macy's? I hope Terry Lundgren isn't expecting us to get all emotional about that. After all, we had 154 years of Fields in 2006 and he bascially said he could care less. Now we all could care less about Macy's.Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 9:13 pm CT
Posted by: A Field's fanGoldman Sachs downgraded Macy's stock a couple of days ago.
"The brokerage cut shares of Macy's and Kohl's from "neutral" to "buy," but maintained its earnings estimates and outlook for the companies. It has a price target of $48 on Kohl's and $21 on Macy's."
http://www.reuters.com/article/rbssConsumerGoodsAndRetailNews/idUSBNG31807220080820Meanwhile, there was another item about Glamorama...this writer claims Macy's started Glamorama. You can respond easily--no need for any login.http://www.examiner.com/x-443-Chicago-Gay-Examiner~y2008m8d21-Glam-it-up-at-Glamorama-08And finally, in case you have missed it, here's the link to yesterday's item from Chicagoist where you can respond:http://chicagoist.com/2008/08/21/80s_faves_to_perform_at_macys_fashi.phpDate: Fri, August 22, 2008 7:54 pm CT
Posted by: JohnDoes anyone know the them for the Messy's windows this year? I envision them using even fewer windows and incorporating more sponsors. A source told me that they would probably reflect the NYC windows, but with a Chicago twist. Already scared...Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 7:03 pm CT
Posted by: SarahHi everyone! I was in NYC this past weekend. I took a bus tour and when we passed Macy's I heard a lot of mumbling and groaning from others about Macy's. I also saw 3 people with tote bags that said Field's Girl on them in LaGuardia while waiting for my flight.Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 6:58 pm CT
Posted by: GailI went shopping this weekend at Tysons Galleria in suburban Washington. While taking my wallet out of my purse to buy a shirt at Thomas Pink, I realized that I had a "Forever Marshall Field's" button in my purse, so I put it on. It didn't take more than 30 seconds for people to start commenting on it. Marshall Field's fans are everywhere.Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 5:16 pm CT
Posted by: gleSorry, not all Chicago will be "She-boppin'" in the front row at Messy's glamorama. And I commend "chicagoist" for admitting "nothing tops" the one Field's started five years ago. I wonder at the logic of anyone trying to look good while being associated with the stigma of Messy's.
I feel much more excited about Field's Fans' upcoming Rally and Book Signing Reception on September 9. I will be there and am passing the information around to friends and co-workers.
Another person in the elevator at work took a leaflet today and wished Field's Fans all the best.
Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 12:09 pm CT
Posted by: TOM ZTHE NAME OF THE LINE OF HOUSEHOLD PRODUCTS WAS 222 INCLUDED SOAPS, TOILET PAPER, ICE MELT, ETC.Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 10:26 am CT
Posted by: EdThis guy writes that Macy's started Glamorama. Please correct him. There's a place to leave a response-----no passwords needed.http://www.examiner.com/x-443-Chicago-Gay-Examiner~y2008m8d21-Glam-it-up-at-Glamorama-08Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 7:23 am CT
Posted by: GI love your cause. I grew up in the Chicago area, and Marshall Field's was always a major shopping destination for my family. I haven't hardly been able to even look at the State St. store since the Macy's take-over. I want my Field's!!Date: Fri, August 22, 2008 2:17 am CT
Posted by: drewHere's an interesting article about the Parisian department stores in the Detroit area:
http://detroit.about.com/od/shopping/a/parisiandetroit.htm
The article notes that Bon Ton was wise to retain the Parisian name to establish a connection to the Detroit area. Perhaps more Parisian stores will open when the economy improves and the stores will earn the loyalty of shoppers who have given upon the Red Star Store.
When I visited family in "the D" this summer, we went to Laurel Park Place in Livonia and enjoyed shopping at Parisian and Von Maur. In the past, shopping always included a visit to JL Hudson's (I just loved the big downtown store on Woodward as a kid) and later Marshall Fields. My cousins laughed about the Red Star Store and said they NEVER even bother going there. One cousin lives 5 minutes from Southland and shopped almost exclusively at Hudson's/Fields. Since the conversion, she said she visited the Red Star once and will drive 40 minutes to Livonia, 20 minutes to Fairlane, or almost an hour to Somerset Collection to shop at a decent department store. Family members in Macomb County said that the now defunct Crowley's was far superior to the Red Star. Seems Kohl's and JC Penney are picking up the mid tier, while Von Maur and Parisian are picking up the better level. Meijer is a fantastic big box, in my opinion, and offers quality discount merchandise. And the Red Star fits into this shopping mix HOW?
The Red Star is evidently a failure in Detroit as well as in Chicago. Pittsburgh shoppers pretty much ignore the place. Friends in Cleveland have said most people don't even bother going into the Red Star; Dillard's has picked up the mid tier Kaufmann's shoppers while Nordstrom and Saks have expanded their offerings in the better tier. Kohl's and JC Penney have upgraded merchandise and improved their stores while the Red Star offers overpriced, poor quality, bland merchandise in a discount store environment. Family members in Baltimore who LOVED bamberger*s/macy*s and liked Hecht's absolutely despise the Red Star Store. One relative said "A gift from THERE would be like getting a gift from Sears--something you won't like, don't need, or wouldn't buy for yourself."
Nobody that I know shops at the Red Star, but I suppose my friends and family are all part of the demographic group no longer desired by Mr Lunkhead.
Date: Thurs, August 21, 2008 11:09 pm CT
Posted by: drewTo Jimmy Gimbels:
It's a shame that you didn't get to visit King of Prussia (outside Philly) in the late 1980s. The huge, beautiful mall featured Philadelphia's beloved Strawbridge and Clothier (later bought by May Company and renamed Strawbridge's), Abraham & Straus, Bloomingdale's (when it was still something unique), bamberger*s (later macy*s, when it was a very classy operation), and the wonderful John Wanamaker and traditional Gimbels at a separate nearby mall called the Court. I believe there were also outposts of Sears and JC Penney, but why would someone from the Pittsburgh area even bother visiting stores that can be found anywhere?
What an exciting day exploring the real department stores that offered a wide variety of merchandise at different price points with house brands that were actually very attractive.
Downtown Philly offered the classy Strawbridge and Clothier, the beautiful John Wanamaker with the magnificant organ in its Grand Court and a new Gimbels (later Sterns). The only remnant of these grand department stores is a mini-macy*mart in a section of the former Wanamaker's.
The "magic of macy*s" has cast its dark spell across the nation!
Date: Thurs, August 21, 2008 10:18 pm CT
Posted by: JPKIn the newest edition of American eagle airlines mag, macy's is offering an 11% discount card for international visitors at any of their stores. More Macy magic to mske their cheap merchandise get off the shelfDate: Thurs, August 21, 2008 6:14 pm CT
Posted by: Jeff S.If I remember correctly, the household products sold by Marshall Field and Company were called "222". I don't know what the 222 stands for; the address is 111, as we all know.
Bring back Marshall Field & Co.!!
Date: Thurs, August 21, 2008 4:07 pm CT
Posted by: John D.Darrid makes a very good point in his posting of Tuesday, August 19 at 8:51 p.m. For those of you who are not familiar with the Cupid Candy deal that Mr. Lundgren promised, here is some background. It just one more in a mile-long string of broken promises.
http://www.chitowndailynews.org/Chicago_news/Sweet_deal_for_local_candy_maker,11512
Question: Since I have not stepped into the State Street store since September 7, 2006, would someone please tell me?---Is the instore RANGO mint demo mini-kitchen that Mr. Lundgren promised to operate, set-up and operating?
Which reminds me: The FRANGO mints were a lucrative money maker for Field's. Buying a box or two or three of FRANGO mints with a day's shopping was the customary norm back in the good ol' days of Marshall Field's! You never left Field's empty handed. The FRANGOs were a natural add-on sale. They were what you took home for family and friends. Tourists took them home, as a sign of Chicago, for family and friends. No more though since they have been macy-fied.
Date: Thurs, August 21, 2008 2:20 pm CT
Posted by: Mike & JimThe hype for Glamorama has picked up. Of course, it was Marshall Field's that started it all but it is now known as "Macy's Glamorama". Yet, as Chicagoist notes today, it's not what it was when Field's started it.
To be sure it is for a worthy cause--it benefits the Art Institute of Chicago--but Chiago needs its fashion and glam developed under a Chicago name and sponsored by a store that represents Chicago at its best.
It's very important that Field's Fans repsond to the Chicagoist article posted at the following URL. If you don't have one, you will need to register a login to post but since Chicagoist posts about our cause with frequency, it's well worth it. See the posting area beneath the article for information on registering a login.
In admiration and respect for all you do to bring back Marshall Field's.
http://chicagoist.com/2008/08/21/80s_faves_to_perform_at_macys_fashi.phpDate: Thurs, August 21, 2008 10:14 am CT
Posted by: Molly A.I just found this site and I'm so glad to see it! I worked for Fields for almost 2 years while working on a nursing degree and if Macy's hadn't closed my store in Fort Wayne I probably would have stayed on just as a temp person. I loved working there and I loved the people and products.Date: Thurs, August 21, 2008 7:13 am CT
Posted by: J.L.I support your work trying to bring back Marshall Fieldsb there has been no other department store that has compared to my experience at Fields. Thanks!Date: Thurs, August 21, 2008 4:59 am CT
Posted by: Jimmy GimbelsHey, it's me, Jimmy Gimbels, reporting live from King of Prussia Mall near Philadelphia. Lord and Taylor is busy. So is Nordstrom and Neiman Marcus. The place is packed with back-to-school shoppers. Well, except for - oh, you already know the answer - MACY'S. And I thought they were the darling of the younger generation...that according to Macy press releases. I told several people about the boycott in Chicago. They all dislike Macy's for the same reasons: poor service...overpriced merch, poor selection. King of Prussia store is yet another example of Macy's lack of attention to maintenance and cleaning.
I believe, in many locations, Macy's gets business only because they are the only game in town. After all, they were allowed to buy out and shut down the competition. But where there is a choice, shoppers go anywhere but Macy's.
I've said it once, I will say it again: The magic of Macy's is how they manage to keep their doors open.
Jimmy Gimbels goes to Macy's King of Prussia so you don't have to.
Date: Wed, August 20, 2008 3:36 pm CT
Posted by: gleI saw our announcement this morning about the September 9 rally at Noon and the reception and book signing at 5:00 p.m. I look forward to attending both events, and am sharing the information with my co-workers.
Even more, I look forward to the eventual return of our Marshall Field's. I walked by the store today, and there were actually cobwebs on the Field's nameplates on the State Street side of the State and Randolph corner. I was sorry not to even have a kleenex handy. Chicago deserves better.
Date: Wed, August 20, 2008 12:50 pm CT
Posted by: Mike CPlease pardon the interruption. I am wondering if anyone rembers the line of household products produced for Marshall Field & Company in the 1970C-s. I believe it was called the 333 brand or something to that effect? As I recall the brand had quite large assortment of products ranging from driveway salt to bathroom tissue all proudly bearing the Marshall Field & Company name. Thank you for your help.Date: Wed, August 20, 2008 10:19 am CT
Posted by: GMy heart is still very much in this drive. I have my cookie jar fashioned like the clock and it's a reminder of better days and the fact that I will not shop Macy's.Date: Wed, August 20, 2008 9:12 am CT
Posted by: TMChicago Cabaret Professionals will be presenting it's Tenth Anniversary Gala at the Park West Theater on Sunday, October 19 at 7:00 PM. The title of the show is "Our Kind of Town". Cabaret artist, Carla Gordon, who wrote "I'll Miss Fields This Christmas," will be performing it in the gala, which is typically attended by over four hundred audience members.Date: Wed, August 20, 2008 9:04 am CT
Posted by: AJL, La Guna Hills, CAI'm with ya!Date: Wed, August 20, 2008 8:36 am CT
Posted by: C.B.As pointed out in the recent Field's newsletter, the problem is not just return of the Marshall Field's name but return of the actual retailer and merchandise...or another more upscale retail emporium. I write Macy's and complain bitterly They have allowed the physical premises of both downtown store locations to degrade shamelessly! They have negatively altered the desirability of living any where near Water Tower because the store, its display windows, its interior plant and merchandise is all ugly and cheap. Macy's is a junk store that belongs in surburban malls alongside other junk stores, not in landmark locations in Chicago's Gold Coast and on venerable State Street. Don't just bring back the Marshall Field's name! Let's boot Macy's out of Chicago, period!Date: Tues, August 19, 2008 8:51 pm CT
Posted by: DarridJust another note...What ever happened to the Cupid Candy deal?
So far they haven't done anything yet and Macy's keeps discontinuing Frango flavors.
What a shock!
Date: Tues, August 19, 2008 7:58 pm CT
Posted by: Big ShopperI just found this website and am sure glad I did. I was downtown today and thought I would walk through "Field's" (I can't help it, it's still Field's to me) and see what Macy's had done to it. I know how shabby my familiar suburban Macy's is (Northbrook Court) but I hoped they were still keeping the main store in good condition. Well, it was just awful. There was torn tape on the floor, cracks all over the first floor and balls of used Kleenex on the Frango display! It really knocked me over. This is truly a tragedy. If there's anything that can be done to change things back to how they were, I'd like to help. I haven't shopped at Macy's much for over a year.Date: Tues, August 19, 2008 6:00 pm CT
Posted by: SimpsoniteI had a chance to visit the Macy's at Twelve Oaks Mall in Novi Michigan over the weekend. It was my first visit to a Macy's since the conversion. The store was busy but it was clear that this was a day for bargain shoppers and not regulars. Most of the stuff on sale was their third rate housebrand stuff like Alfani. Most of the designer stuff seemed like it came from all of the "lower tier" lines of the major designers. I had a look at a shirt that didn't seem as shabby as the others, but of course, it was one of the one's that was not on sale. Why am I not surprised?
The store itself seemed to have traces of greatness that were slowly been irradicated by the ongoing "improvements" being made. The store seemed way too bright and cold feeling as opposed to the more subdued Lord and Taylor and Nordstrom's elsewhere in the mall that made shopping a more enjoyable experience. There were quite a few Macy's bags in the mall but there were way more from Lord and Taylor (always a good sign).
I browsed through the candy department and had a look through the Frango's (most of which still had the Field's logo on them). I noticed quite a few boxes still had the May company designation on the back which seems to suggest that they were quite a few years old.
Overall, the store was what I expected. I saw reminents of what appeared to be a nice store that is in dire need of rescue from Macy's Inc. I really don't see them lasting too long - at least not until they fire Lundgren and replace him with someone who is prepared to go back to the basics and start rebuilding consumer goodwill from scratch. The Macy's name is probably beyond saving at this point outside of their traditional eastern / Pacific corridors.
When I saw their new anniversary catchphrase, I just wanted to laugh. I thought it should read "Macy's: Inspiring Ews, Augghs and Ows for the past 150 years." Yuk!
Date: Tues, August 19, 2008 1:40 pm CT
Posted by: Michael RussellIs there a way that we could forward this blog to Macy's customer relations or to the board? (Like they don't know it exists!!!!) Maybe some of the board members could read what people want, and what they experience when going into these dreadful stores. Another thought is to send photos of these messy Macy stores right to corporate headquarters. Sounds like a job for Jimmy Gimbels!!!!
Press on!!!!!!!!
Date: Tues, August 19, 2008 1:36 pm CT
Posted by: GaylePoor Jimmy Gimbels, I'm still laughing 24 hours after reading your post! I appreciate the sacrifices you make, going to Macy's so we don't have to!
I wonder, are Macy's managers kicking out kids that walk through the store wearing Abercrombie & Fitch t-shirts? How about employees from other stores who walk through wearing store nametags? Or is all this hostility directed just toward Field's fans?
You'd think they'd be happy just to have a warm body enter the store other than their funereal employees.
Just when I think that Macy's cannot possibly become any more arrogant and mean-spirited--when I start to believe they've done absolutely everything in their power to anger, disrespect, alienate, or otherwise annoy potential shoppers--they come up with a new despicable policy.
Thanks for the "field report" Jimmy!
Date: Mon, August 18, 2008 10:20 pm CT
Posted by: mja1951I have noticed a number of posting where they state that Macy's should bring back Marshall Field's.
It's my opinion that Macy's could not be trusted to bring back Field's as an upscale store. Remember the "We're bringing back Field Gear" sham, and all their other phony attempts since they took over.
I wonder how many people really believe that if Macy's brought back Field's it would be little more than re-branding the Macy's crap with different labels and the same lack of personalized service.
I really want Field's back, but only as the Marshall Field's we remembered, with quality merchandise, fair prices, and great service.
Perhaps you could have a survey of how many people could trust Macy's to bring back Field's properly. I believe Macy's would have to sell the Field's stores to another company.
Response from webmaster:
No survey is needed--simply read the many posts below from over the past two years or more and you will see that the overwhelming majority believe as "mja1951" believes.
Date: Mon, August 18, 2008 9:59 pm CT
Posted by: gayleToday a young female colleague of my husband's came by his office to ask a question. She is likely the target demographic that Macy's hopes to entice. While she was there, she noticed his Field's button stuck on his bulletin board. She said "I hate Macy's! I only shop there for the sales." Hubby asked why should would patronize such a store, even for sales. She said "You don't understand...they close out stuff for, like, 75% off!" After a moment's thought, she admitted that she really disliked the store, and was "creeped out" by what they had done to Field's. Before she left, she swore to join the boycott.
It really didn't take anything to convince her---Macy's lack of service and quality had already pushed her to the edge.
Date: Mon, August 18, 2008 CT
Posted by: A Field's FanHappy 174th Birthday to the founder of Marshall Field and Company, Marshall Field I, born on this date in Conway, Massachusetts.
He inspired more oohs and ahhs in one year than Macy's ever did in 150 years!
Date: Mon, August 18, 2008 6:30 pm CT
Posted by: PeterRegading dunnhumby USA, the UK company opened a USA division at the behest of Kroger. Kroger is the parent of Food4Less stores in the Chicago area. Korger headquarters are right down the street from Macy's HQ.
And guess what? Two of Macy's board members were or are Kroger execs. Gee, like we're not on to them!
Date: Mon, August 18, 2008 12:14 pm CT
Posted by: Meredith KI am glad you are going through with this site and keeping up the fight. The funny thing is, this reminds me of when Hudson's became Field's in Detroit. Except that no one really boycotted, because Fields was much more respectable and less hostile than Macy's has been. I grew up in the Metro Detroit area, and I remember my mother and grandfather being very upset about the change from Hudson's to Marshall Fields. Because I was young, I didn't mind so much, as long as we could still get Saunders' cream puffs and Maurice Salad!. I feel that Marshall Fields did a great job of preserving all that was nostalgic and respectable about good old Hudson's. I have been a Field's shopper since I got my license!. I moved to Chicago a little over two years ago (and a little before Macy's took Field's away), and I remember being excited to buy EVERYTHING I needed for my little apartment at the State Street Field's store. Unfortunately, Macy's came and took over. I have notices a decline in customer service, quality of merchandise, and most of all sanitation. Even if they served my beloved Maurice Salad in that smelly cafeteria downstairs, I wouldn't want to eat it.
If I can't have Hudson's back, I want Marshall Fields back. A place that serves favorite classic food and stocks my favorite clothing lines, not a place that reminds me of an overpriced discount shopping store.
Please keep up the good work for me and everyone else who misses Hudson's as well.
Date: Sun, August 17, 2008 8:28 pm CT
Posted by: Greg J.The newest edition of RETAIL WIRE newsletter (www.retailwire.com) features a main article on: How Macy's is Trying to Better Relate to Customers. Several comments by professional retail strategists conclude with a point that is well-founded.
Macy's seems to feel that as long as they continue to do so-called surveys and go through the motions of hiring studies being done, they should saatisfy everyone. Not true. More and more people are realizing that his plan is doomed to failure. His plan is not working and it will not ever work. Terry Lundgren is going to have to realize that he will need to actually DO what the studies indicate---to listen, to REALLY l-i-s-t-e-n to the customers and to back-step and implement what the customers want if Macy's is to continue.
In the comment section, several professional retail experts, call Mr. Lundgren's plastering the macy's name on the former regional department stores, as a mistake.
Date: Sun, August 17, 2008 4:14 pm CT
Posted by: drewI had to drop off some friends at Pittsburgh International Airport on Saturday evening, so I decided to visit nearby Beaver Valley Mall. Boscov's (formerly an outpost of Pittsburgh's "carriage trade" department store Joseph Horne Company, later Lazarus) was quite busy; this location is NOT being shuttered. The mall traffic was brisk and I noticed many Boscov's and JC Penney shopping bags but very few Red Star bags. JC Penney was also busy and there were lines at several check outs.
I then ventured to the Red Star store (originally Gimbels, converted to Kaufmann's). The elegant plexiglass "billboards" celebrating the 150th Anniversary were everywhere. In the center of the store near the escalators, a large plexiglass "billboard" featured a timeline of the "exciting" history of the store. The timeline curtly mentioned that "other stores" became macy*s in 2006. I thought the other side of the billboard would have some other information, but it was a duplicate of the same timeline.
The store WAS neat and clean. Although there were a good number of people walking through the store, there weren't many folks carrying shopping bags or making purchases. I walked through both floors and there was really nothing to catch my interest. Pillows were "Buy One Get One Free" but every pillow I checked felt as though it would pack down in no time; I need an ultra firm pillow and these were ultra light.
The men's clothing department was drab and unexciting. While there was a lot of "stuff" on display, the merchandise looked just like what's already in your closet. Nothing worth more than a cursory glance. In fact, JC Penney had a wider and more varied selection of clothes.
Date: Sun, August 17, 2008 2:17 pm CT
Posted by: Paul J. FreistuhlerI'm from Chicago but have lived in NYC for 16 years. To say I was surprised the first time I walked into Macy's here is an understatement. I really thought "what a dump" because I could not help but compare it with my beloved Marshall Fields on State Street.
About 12 years ago, I moved two blocks from Macy's on 34th St. Although I have never been particularly fond of Macy's, I have occasionally shopped there for emergency purchases (usually a last minute gift).
I knew Macy's was buying up department stores across the country and perhaps in some cases, they actually made the store more upscale than it's previous incarnation but I doubt this happened much. Then I heard they were buying Fields. I remember thinking, "well, with this purchase, there is no way they can change the name to Macy's. They'll have to keep the Fields name or there will be outrage and demonstrations--no one will shop there!" I knew this because Marshall Fields was more than a department store to Chicagoans. It was a best friend, a tradition and a first for so many things. I lived near Woodfield as a kid and as a teenager and I would always be excited to go to Marshall Fields and buy something. I would walk proudly all over the mall with my signiture green bag and show off that I indeed had something special. It had to be special because it was from Fields! I remember buying my first "designer" bathing suit, getting my first "nice outfit" for a school dance at Rolling Meadows High school, and of course, always getting at least a small box of Frangomints.
Of course the biggest thrill of all was getting to go downtown and shopping at State Street. This was always a special event and I would look forward to it for months! I moved into the city when I was 18 and I remember clearly the day I got my very first credit card. Yes, it was from my fried, Marshall Fields! Oh the excitement! The next day I headed right for State Street as it just happened to be "Field Days", that once a month special Sunday that the State Street store was open. I remember buying my first ever coffee pot and some fancy flavored coffees and I thought that I had finally entered adulthood!
When family came to town, We would always make a trip to Fields on State Street because it was Magic. Everyone had the biggest smiles and one of these times was the first time I ever bought my Mom a dress. So many firsts, yes, Marshall Fields was my best friend because it is with best friends that you do experience "firsts". Every gift I bought would come from this store, for all occasions.
Later I would work for a perfume company and I would always ask my boss to put me at Fields State Street whenever possible because this is where people were the happiest customers. It was actually fun to work there.
Even after moving to NYC, I would make a trip at least twice a year to Chicago and I would always make it a point to take whatever friend I had with me from NY to State Street Fields. They would ALWAYS be blown away by the beauty and service that was this marvelous shopping experience. Yes, it made shopping "An Experience"!
Well, when I heard Macy's was in fact changing the name, I felt sick and sad. I refuse to shop at Macy's here in NY now, not even for "emergency" gifts. I visited my family last October and we went to Woodfield, my childhood playground. I took a tour of the "Macy's" there and honestly, could not find even one thing to buy. The quality and selection was appalling. Gone were all the stylish brands I used to know there and in their place was shoddy Alfani, cheap, lack luster brands, and hip hop clothes that were already out of fashion (not that I would ever have considered this type of clothing anyway). Later when we wnet downtown, I could not even bring myself to visit my once beloved store on State Street.
I think it is important to share fond stories about Marshall Fields, not just argue that their sales are down. Emotions are often important arguments for change.
The Macy'sfication of America is a terrible idea. Top level people should be fired. Bring back variety and tradition. Macy's could have entered the Chicago market and people would have shopped there too as long as Macy's didn't take away the most loved department store in the country. Before I moved to NYC, I always wondered "why isn't Macy's coming to Chicago? They could open across the street from Fields State Street in that big empty lot, build on new stores at malls as Nordstrom's and other's had, etc." Perhaps it would have been an exciting trip to also go to Macy's, heck I didn't' know what they were like". That might have worked too because Macy's is completely different to any shopping experience in Chicago. I know at one point there once was a cachet to the Macy's name (although I don't get it) but I'm afraid it is too late now for Macy's in Chicago.
I won't shop there and I hope other's will make this same decision and force them to close. Do the right thing Macy's and give Marshall Fields back to Chicago! Has any buy out of a store ever upset so many people and to a degree where they are continuing to demonstrate years later? It is time to realize this was an extremely bad business decision and to rectify it. Have we heard even one person say they like Macy's better than Fields? Not a one that I'm aware of. NOT ONE!
Until then, Bad Macy's, Bad.
Date: Sun, August 17, 2008 12:56 am CT
Posted by: Fields Fan 123How every you slice, dice, or chop it... Macy's has failed in the Midwest and beyond. Sales, profits, customer service, all down - WAY down.
My prediction is the following stores will close:
- Vernon Hills
- Northbrook Court
- Woodfield Furniture
They are always empty and even when they make a sale it is at a huge discount (low margin). There is no way they can stay in business. Macy's would rather break the lease (pay a fee) and leave.
Date: Sun, August 17, 2008 12:22 am CT
Posted by: James in MinneapolisToday's Star Tribune had an article stating that since JB Hudson Jewelers moved out of the corner of the Nicollet Mall Store, macy's has not been able to attract a replacement tenant. The Pohlad family (Minnesota Twins baseball team) bought the jeweler from the Cargill family (Cargill grain traders) and then moved the store down Nicollet Mall one block into much bigger space.
In order to fill the space that has now sat empty in the macy's store since last winter, macys has decided to put the Xmas decorations in that space this year, instead of on fifth floor. And in order to get the space filled quickly, the Xmas stuff will go in there on September 15.
It really is an elegant space and it housed the jewelers since The Dayton family owned it in 1929. However, I am uncertain how the tacky Xmas decorations will look in there and I am repulsed by the thought of it being in there on September 15.
Regards.
Date: Sat, August 16, 2008 10:34 pm CT
Posted by: SteveThe Trib has had several on-line articles about retail including some success at JCPenney and the drop in sales at Macy's.
There are places to leave comments after these--you should do so!
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/sns-ap-retail-earns-glance,0,6599929.story
http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/chi-sat-penney-abercrombie-earniaug16,0,7122004.story
Date: Sat, August 16, 2008 12:01 pm CT
Posted by: Sarah, WisconsinThe board of directors at Macy's must be all puppets for Terry Lundgren. Any sane retailer would switch back to Field's after a sustained 5% reduction in sales. Macy's seems to be just trying to hide its mistake of getting rid of Marshall Field's.Date: Sat, August 16, 2008 5:22 am CT
Posted by: J CRetailWire has a fascinating article on Macy's attempts at understanding customers' needs and wants. Overall, many of the opinions posted by retail experts at this link do not think Macy's is "getting it".
Be sure to take part in the poll!
http://www.retailwire.com/Discussions/Sngl_Discussion.cfm/13167#pollDate: Sat, August 16, 2008 4:02 am CT
Posted by: JBI hate Macy's!!Date: Sat, August 16, 2008 12:51 am CT
Posted by: MCincinnati-based article about Macy's 2Q figures:
"Macy's finds a tear in its fabric"
http://www.journalinquirer.com/articles/2008/08/15/business/doc48a321cf93a4e213386094.txtDate: Sat, August 16, 2008 12:00 am CT
Posted by: Jimmy GimbelsThose wacky folks at Macy's are turning nasty again. I was walking through the Macy's at Westfield Hawthorne (to get to Carson's) when a manager type told me to leave the store. She saw the Field's button on my jacket and said "If your aren't going to buy anything, you should just leave. This is private property."
Two shoppers standing nearby heard the exchange and chimed in with, "You are so rude just like the rest of the sales people. We're out of here, too!" The store sure was empty for a Friday night at 6:00 PM.
Gee, I didn't even get to check if the Frango Mints from Christmas 2006 were still on sale in what is left of the candy/gift food department.
Jimmy Gimbels goes to Macy's - and gets kicked out - so you don't have to! By the way, lots of nice fall clothing and helpful salepeople at Carson's. They love to see people wearing Field's buttons.
Date: Fri, August 15, 2008 5:34 pm CT
Posted by: SteveWhile the Sun-Times ran the AP story about Macy's 2Q results, the print edition had a different story. It was simply a Business Briefs blurb headlined with the bit about Macy's hiring dumbhumby to (duh) find out what customers want. Then the 2Q financials were tacked on afterwards. They sure swept that under the rug! But my, what a big bulge there is under that rug! It's obvious to everyone!
You can write a letter to the editor at letters@suntimes.com
Date: Fri, August 15, 2008 1:35 pm CT
Posted by: LiMackMany many Chicagoans warned Macy's they would boycott if/when Marshall Field's was disrespected, and have carried through on that threat by not spending a dime at Macy's. Others, however, became Macy's boycotters by accident, so to speak. This is because during their forays into the stores potential shoppers have discovered there is no reason whatsoever to shop at Macy's. The service stinks, the merchandise is downgraded and the stores are messy and not well maintained. There are plenty of other more pleasant places to go and spend your hard earned dollars.
It would no doubt be instructional for Terry Lundgren to put on a disguise--glasses, false nose, wig, whatever and make a few private, unannounced visits to his stores across the country---not as CEO, but as a regular customer. THEN he might understand exactly what average shoppers see, experience, and are subjected to when they go into a Macy's store these days. He might better understand why shoppers are not beating down the doors to partake of the "magic of Macy's".
Date: Fri, August 15, 2008 8:45 am CT
Posted by: gleOne of Terry Lunkhead's recent quotes has him saying they continue to outperform most of their major competitors. I wonder if he knows exactly who is becoming their competition.
One block from State Street, is a simple Chicago tradition that nobody has managed to stamp out--Farmers' Market. Every week I see more crowds and enthusiasm there than you ever see at Macy's. Vendors such as the Amish (luscious Dutch apple pie), Chicago Coalition for the Homeless (fantastic fair trade coffee from Nigeria), and brilliant cut flowers sell out early while Macy's sales associates stand around chatting and yawning.
When I remind co-workers it is Farmers' Market day, their eyes light up. After lunch we talk about what we found there and what we had to eat. Nobody in my company ever talks that way about Messy's. They say they hate Messy's, and thank me for the Marshall Field's buttons and wish Field's Fans all the best.
Date: Fri, August 15, 2008 8:12 am CT
Posted by: Valencia CarterI have for sell Marshall Fields memorabilia form 1948-1953, it is a very old book with news adds of the old Marshall Fields beauty salon, when I worked there they were going to toss it out so I took it, not knowing that the store would be no more. Please contact me if anyone is interested @ mrsruffone@yahoo.com.Date: Fri, August 15, 2008 1:51 am CT
Posted by: DavidOne is tempted to laugh reading these posts- IF it weren't so tragic.
Like "Zelda" I won't even buy a beverage from macy's and folks at work made it known loud and clear they didn't want gift certificates from there last holiday season- or for their birthdays or bonuses. It's heartbreaking on so many counts, but watching the Loop revival without Chicago's beloved Marshall Field's truly is devastating. Yes, a department store is still in operation at 111 N. State, but nothing that differentiates itself from all the drab big boxes in Anytown, USA.
"Richard in Houston" undoubtedly is right about the lack of business at the former Foley's; I witnessed the same when there in early June; however, macy's may be right as well. Maybe compared to their other failures it IS one of their more profitable markets. Spin is spin. But as the late, great Daniel Patrick Moynihan said: "Everyone is entitled to their own opinion but not to their own facts."
Date: Fri, August 15, 2008 1:18 am CT
Posted by: Richard in
